Who doesn’t love a good ol’ fashioned Top Ten List? No one I know, that’s for sure. Certainly one of the most lamentable facts of living in the Northeast is that we are no longer on “Central Time,” and thus, our beloved Letterman watching days are too far in our past. Who can stay up that late? When did I become this middle-aged woman who has to be in bed by eleven? What is HAPPENING to me?
Eh hem. I think my existential crisis of these recent days might be overtaking my subconscious. My apologies.
As I was saying. . .
With our seminary days winding down, Peter and I decided that we needed to reflect on these special first years of our marriage by having some kind of written record of the things we want to remember. So, I proposed that we write a series of Top Ten Lists pertaining to these days in our lives. Hence, we will be providing these on our blog. We hope you find them entertaining and even, perhaps, useful in some way.
The first of our Top Ten Lists will be easy for us to write and for you to read, the Top Ten Books We Read In Seminary. I now humbly submit my list, and Peter’s will follow shortly. Enjoy!
Megan’s Top Ten Books Read in Seminary
Disclaimer: These are in no particular order. Also, we are not receiving royalties or advertising revenue. Though, we wish. Just wanted to clarify.
1. Discovering a Sermon: Personal Pastoral Preaching by Robert C. Dykstra. My first week of seminary, I walked into a class called “Confession and Forgiveness in Pastoral Perspective.” The professor, the author of this book, introduced the class with opening remarks about how the class was primarily about shame. He began to tell stories– of his own life, of the lives of others– and by the end of the class I was fighting back the tears that were welling up inside me. Peter leaned over to me and said, “You know you have to take this class” (I had been considering dropping it from my already too-packed load). And I did. And it changed my life. And I quickly decided that I would take as many classes with Dykstra as I possibly could. And I have. And they have all, in some way, changed my life. In one class, “Pastor as Person,” this book was assigned, and it confirmed for me some of what I had already suspected of myself as a preacher. It also, as it happened, changed my life.
2. Name All the Animals: A Memoir by Alison Smith. In that first class I took with Dykstra, he assigned us to read some of the most wonderful books I have ever read, particularly books about people’s lives. I have always been fascinated by the story of people’s lives, and I think that part of what I have always found so compelling about the Gospels in particular and the Bible in general is that the story of lives and the Story of the Life is told and re-told and told again, and I am so captivated by it that I cannot put it down and walk away– even when I have wanted to. This book is a story of a life, and it captivated me with its beautiful, nonjudgmental writing and reflection about life.
3. My First White Friend: Confessions on Race, Love, and Forgiveness by Patricia Raybon. Another life story. Another beautifully written reflection. Ever since my forray into the Deep South during my few (lost!) years in Tuscaloosa, Alabama, I have been fascinated by the American project of all of these different-shades-of-skinned-people living under the same American sky on the same American land. I have been equally fascinated by the way that the Christian Church in America (no, that’s not a denomination) has found ways to speak, respond, and exist in such a community. My experience and judgment has led me to the conclusion that, by and large, we have failed. Miserably. But I think that sharing our stories with one another might be a starting place. This book has been one such starting place for me.
4. The Fire Next Time by James Baldwin. Along with Professor Dykstra, Professor Yolanda Pierce has had a tremendous impact on me here at Princeton. She has taught not only with her great mind but with her heart and soul as well. I took her “African-American Religious History” course in the fall of 2007, and it, too, changed my life. This was one of the many wonderful books/readings that she assigned, and the minute I was finished reading it through the first time, I turned to the first page and read it over again. It is, for me, a flawless combination of my interest in life stories and race in America.
A snippet:
“I rushed home from school, to the church, to the altar, to be alone there, to commune with Jesus, my dearest Friend, who would never fail me, who knew all the secrets of my heart. Perhaps He did, but I didn’t, and the bargain we struck, actually, down there at the foot of the cross, was that He would never let me find out.
“He failed His bargain. He was a much better Man than I took Him for” (34).
5. The Souls of Black Folk by W.E.B. DuBois. Again, this is a Dr. Pierce-assigned-life-changing-reader. I am ashamed that it took me until I was 26 years old to read this book in full. This book took me away from my presumptions and assumptions and assertions and solutions, and it helped me to start from scratch in precisely the areas I thought that I knew all about. Seriously. Go read this book.
6. Gilead by Marilynne Robinson. This Pulitzer-Prize-winning novel is simply flawless. I have learned more from reading this book about pastoral ministry and human beings than I have in entire semesters of theology or church history. (Granted, that may also be because I actually read the entire book by its assigned due date! Still. . . ) Dr. Pierce assigned this as a text in another life-changing and soul-enriching class of hers, “Writing as Faith Practice.”
7. The Complete Stories of Flannery O’Connor. Dr. Pierce assigned this in “Writing as Faith Practice.” If there is anyone who knew how to practice faith through writing, it was Flannery O’Connor. Seriously, how had I not known this woman’s awesomeness until now?! These stories are haunting and entrancing, and I have not yet finished the entire book simply because I don’t want to be parted with it for too long. It sits on my bedside table, on top of my Kierkegaard (maybe as a buffer?), and I pick it up and read a page or two each day. So far, my favorites are “Judgement Day,” “Greenleaf,” “Good Country People,” and “The Life You Save May Be Your Own.” But even trying to narrow down favorites is a futile exercise. They’re all amazing, and my favorite is really whichever one I’m currently reading, which right now is “The Train.”
8. The Undertaking: Life Studies From the Dismal Trade by Thomas Lynch. And, we’re back to a Dykstra class. In “Pastor as Person,” which, by the way, I merely audited (but read more for than some of the other classes I took for credit that semester!), Dykstra spent some time talking about death. Light, cheery, seminary stuff. Actually, I have no idea why this never sunk in before, but this time we spent in class was when and where it finally hit me that, if I really do this whole pastoring thing, I’m going to have to perform FUNERALS. FOR DEAD PEOPLE. (Well, technically, for the living, because, as Lynch is careful to reiterate, “the dead don’t care” [5]). FUNERALS OF PEOPLE THAT I KNOW. WELL. AND, SOME THAT I LOVE. A LOT. It is easy to get caught up with all the fun and games of pastoral counseling, of preaching and teaching, of organizing and administrating, of helping and loving, of molding and shaping, of listening. But, on occasion, those very people that you have counseled and preached and taught and organized and helped and loved and shaped. . . will die. And the living will turn, in some part, to you. To me. Ponder that, and then go read this book.
9. Sing! a new creation. Ok, so this is technically not the kind of book you or I probably had in mind at the start of this project, but I would really be remiss not to mention the enormous impact that it has had on my understanding, appreciation, and expansion of worship resources. It is “the green book” in the pews of Miller Chapel, and it is filled with wonderful hymns, praise choruses, psalms, and global music that have been an important part of my “unofficial” education at Princeton Seminary. If you are a musician, like I suppose I am, you probably spend an inordinate amount of time scrutinizing and pondering the music in church. This is a great resource, in my opinion, for anyone who is granted the remarkable task of leading and planning worship for Christian communities.
10. Welp, I don’t have a tenth yet. There are about thirty books I could place here, but I’m currently in another Dykstra class, “Sexuality and the Christian Body,” and I’m banking on number ten coming from this class, so I’ll keep you posted. If it doesn’t, I guess I have some more narrowing down to do. Or who knows, maybe we’ll have a surprise upset in this last semester. After all, I am in a Children’s Fantasy Literature class right now, and I must say that it is a blasty-blast, and I sure loved reading Twilight. Oh the days of my womanly, adolescent longings! Where have you gone to, my lovely?


